On
March 15, 1998, a cultural icon died at the ripe old age of
94.
Benjamin
Spock began work on his famous "Baby and Child Care" in 1943,
at the request of Donald Porter Geddes of Pocket Books. He intended
the book to combine "sound pediatrics and sound psychology."
While serving in the Navy as a psychiatrist from 1944 to 1946,
he finished the manuscript.
The first
edition, illustrated by Dorothea Fox, was published in 1946,
just as the postwar baby boom began. Selling nearly 50 million
copies in 30 languages, it became the number two best-seller
in America, with only the Bible outpacing it.
The book
was written for mothers, who he correctly assumed would be the
primary caretakers of children in middle-class homes. His work
appeared at a time when the average age at marriage was dropping
rapidly, and millions of middle-class women were leaving college
and jobs to devote themselves full-time to caring for their
homes and children. "Expertise" was in fashion, too. Ironically,
Spock became one of the most trusted experts in the nation by
telling parents to "trust themselves."
The secret
of Spock's success was simple. He told parents to react spontaneously
to their children, to give them love, cuddles, food and discipline
when they felt it was appropriate--not according to a rigid
schedule. This philosophy was widely interpreted as permissive,
and was blamed by many commentators for the self-indulgent behavior
of the baby boomers--both in the 1960's and up to the present
day.
But, there
is a strange duality to the book's theme. Beneath the veneer
of advising parents to trust themselves, he instilled fears
into them, as well. A lifelong Freudian, Spock persuaded two
generations of American mothers that nursing, weaning, tickling,
playing, toilet training, and other activities inherent in childhood
are not the innocuous behaviors they appear to be at first glance.
Such activities, according to Spock, are psychic minefields
that determine a child's lifelong personality traits, and maternal
missteps on such terrain can result in disabling and irrevocable
oral, anal, or Oedipal scars.
Freud hypothesized
that botched toilet training leads to a number of possible "problems,"
ranging from homosexual orientation to paranoia to a fixation
with order.
In his 1992
book, "Freudian Fraud: The Malignant Effect of Freud's Theory
on American Thought and Culture," E. Fuller Torrey summarizes
more than two dozen studies that attempted to substantiate a
link between toilet training and personality traits. No such
link was ever found. Twin and adoption studies, says Torrey,
suggest that "parents have much less effect on their children
than we have been led to believe - or would like to believe."
Spock became
radicalized in 1962, when he felt betrayed by John Kennedy pursuing
nuclear testing. Despite his left-wing leanings, he was increasingly
attacked by the feminists, who blamed him for making women believe
that they were largely responsible for their children's development
and that full-time mothering was essential.
In the 1970s,
Spock revised his book in response to feminist criticisms and
decreasing sales. "Baby and Child Care" now discusses the participation
of fathers, sitters, and day-care centers in child rearing and
alternates the pronouns "he" and "she" when referring to children.
Ever the
secular humanist, he stated in 1985, "I don't believe I go up
to heaven and look down through a peephole to see how I've done.
But, I know that I can help create an afterlife by influencing
those who will come after me."
If anyone
understands what this means, please enlighten me.