A large
part of the fallout from the Columbine High School massacre
is the age old pretense that we have it so bad, and no generation
had it as bad as we do.
Of course,
people have been saying this since the dawn of time. In what
has become a very tired cliche at nearly every high school graduation,
a student gives a speech which includes words decrying the younger
generation--only to reveal that the message was written by Socrates.
Sad to say,
the good ol' days weren't all that good. If kids weren't necessarily
shot down in cold blood at school, they were surely dying of
polio, influenza, and all sorts of childhood diseases in years
past.
What about
movie violence? It was ALWAYS with us, from the earliest days.
One can argue that it is more explicit and graphic now, but
in their time, crime flicks, war pics, and the uncensored version
of King Kong (1933) replete with four sailors being eaten alive
by giant spiders, were harsh indeed.
For sheer
voyeuristic, lurid implied violence thrills, no film made holds
a candle to Freaks (1932). For those aware of the plot, the
film's original ending showed Hercules singing soprano in Madame
Tetralini's new sideshow, but due to intense test audience reactions
this scene was cut. Is castration violent enough for you?
While my
knowledge of pop music history is certainly not all encompassing,
I am confident that the equivalent of a Marilyn Manson could
be found in any generation. Remember, we are not comparing the
artists, or the repertoire, we are comparing the IMPACT that
the artist or work had in its own time. WE may not be shocked
by earlier efforts, but the contemporary audiences may well
have been.
How about
politicians? I'm cynical enough to believe that they were always
corrupt. Bill Clinton will never match Caligula, and our questionable
foray into the Balkans pales next to WWI and its overpraised
big brother, WWII.
What about
morality and spirituality? Sorry, folks, but those were always
in short supply. If things were so great in ancient times, why
did St. Paul have to write all those epistles scolding and encouraging
the early church members? But still, even in times of moral
turpitude, there was also great holiness. Rodrigo Borgia may
have bought the papacy in 1492, but this era also produced some
of the greatest saints in history.
There will
always be a snake oil salesman close at hand, with the latest
"cure," whether it be a government program, another drug, or
a blue ribbon commission. Before we blame all sorts of external
factors for the current state of affairs, or even the current
state of ourselves, we had best look in the mirror.
Glorification
of the past is just one more method that humans use to cope.
Don't buy into it.