This Julia
Roberts vehicle is one of the summer's big hits. I would imagine
that it was intended as a "woman's movie" as well as a date
movie.
Roberts
plays Julianne Potter, a New York food critic, who finds out
that her best friend, Michael O'Neal (Dermot Mulroney), is about
to get married. What to do? Sure enough!! Take the next plane
to Chicago to try to win back Michael.
Once in
Chicago, Julianne resorts to all sorts of nefarious and cruel
schemes to break up Michael and Kimmy (Cameron Diaz). Her confidant
and helper in crime is her gay editor, George (Rupert Everett).
The theory
is that Roberts is playing against type as the "bad girl," and
somehow the audience will be stupid enough to think that ol'
Pretty Woman will win out. Never mind that Kimmy is much more
attractive in every possible way.
The "surprise"
ending, of course, is that Julianne loses, and that Michael
and Kimmy will probably live happily ever after. The real surprise
is that despite all the terrible scheming, Kimmy and Julianne
kiss and make up--and then George and Julianne dance.
We can
assume that George and Julianne will return to their neurotic
New Yorker lives, none the worse for wear. In this feature,
crime did pay. She has all that fun being a bitch, and now gets
to go back to life as it was before. Remember, she was getting
along just fine without Michael when the film started. Ah, Hollywood!!
Now for
the woman's movie stereotypes:
The best
looking, most desirable girl is never voted prom queen if the
girls have anything to say about it. Thus, the women in the
audience will be rooting for Julianne.
The urge
for female bonding is so strong that Kimmy and Julianne get
together in the end, regardless of everything that happened
before.
Gay men
are oh so sensitive, and are babe magnets, presumably because
they are non-threatening. God forbid that Julianne could have
a happily married male or female confidant.
And, now,
the biggie: The basic theme is that "Love is a tragedy." This
is the ultimate theme of all women's literature and film.
Most women
deny these stereotypes, yet they are always used successfully
in the movies. But ladies, don't feel bad. Men are simplistic,
as well. The theme of all men's films is revenge.
Just think.
If we can combine love is a tragedy with revenge, we should
have a killer hit!! But, then again, whatever happened to "Legends
of the Fall?" I guess there isn't a formula, after all...