The news
media has been full of stories on the conviction of Louise Woodward,
the British au pair accused of killing 8 month old Matthew Eappen.
There is an unprecedented outpouring of sympathy, not for Matthew's
parents, but for the convicted killer. Just what is going on
here?
In researching
this piece, I read nearly 30 articles, and not one of them raised
the one big obvious question. Matthew died of massive head trauma,
and he was in Louise's care at the time. If she didn't do it,
how did it occur? Indeed, amazingly enough, no alternative explanation
of the injuries, credible or otherwise, was offered by the defense.
They just...happened.
The best
that defense attorney Barry Scheck (he of the O. J. Simpson
trial fame) could come up with is a re-interpretation of autopsy
photos, which "proved" that the skull fracture that led to the
baby's death occurred prior to February 4, 1997--the day he
was rushed to the hospital. Therefore, Louise didn't do anything
to him that day. What Miss Woodward could have done to Matthew
on any other date was not disclosed.
Scheck
complained that he was not able to present this "powerful" evidence
to the jury. Sorry, Barry, but not every jury is quite as idiotic
as the one you faced in LA--the one that believed that the defendant
didn't match his own DNA. I guess you're losing your touch.
But again,
why the huge sympathy for Louise Woodward? Matthew's mother,
Deborah, touched on it in a CNN interview. "The idea that someone
who looks normal or friendly or young or...I hate to use stereotypes...a
young white soft-spoken British accent, intelligent girl--could
harm your child, it's terrifying to people."
That's
right. White middle class America and Britain can't stomach
the fact that a white middle class girl could murder a child.
The only alternative is denial. And, what is denial other than
the dissociation of cause and effect?
Good Lord,
they reason, if SHE could do it, then I could do it!
My message
to those in denial: You already do! You participate in and accept
abortion and euthanasia, never talking directly about them.
Instead, you talk about rights and choice, quality of life,
and other circumlocutions.
The evidence
be damned. Louise can't possibly be guilty. White middle class
girls just don't do those kind of things.
Sad to
say, they surely do. And, when the only perceptible reaction
is denial, more's the pity.